You're articulate and logical. And your attention to detail is unmatched. Nothing escapes your critical eye because you always want things to be better, whether systems, projects, or yourself.
Any career that taps your verbal abilities, analytical mind, and perfectionism would suit you to a T (which you would never forget to cross). Set aside the practicalities for a moment and do something a bit out of character.
Listen to your heart. What stirs your soul? Forty years from now, what will you wish you had done? That's your new career goal. It doesn't matter so much what degree you got, but what experiences and skills you have to offer.